Step 1 :First, we check Brendan's factoring: $8y^2 - 12y - 18 = 2(4y^2 - 6y - 9)$
Step 2 :Now, we try to factor the quadratic inside the parentheses: $4y^2 - 6y - 9$
Step 3 :We notice that the quadratic is not a perfect square, so we cannot factor it as $(2y - 3)^2$
Step 4 :Therefore, Brendan's factoring is incorrect, and the correct factoring should be $2(4y^2 - 6y - 9)$