Step 1 :Let x be the number of $0.10$ increases in ticket price, and let y be the number of people attending the dance.
Step 2 :The ticket price is $4 + 0.10x$, and the attendance is $300 - 5x$.
Step 3 :The revenue is the product of the ticket price and the attendance: $(4 + 0.10x)(300 - 5x)$.
Step 4 :We want to find the value of x when the revenue is $1237.50$: $(4 + 0.10x)(300 - 5x) = 1237.50$.
Step 5 :Expanding the equation: $1200 - 20x + 0.10x^2 - 0.50x^2 = 1237.50$.
Step 6 :Simplifying the equation: $-0.40x^2 - 20x + 1200 = 1237.50$.
Step 7 :Subtract 1237.50 from both sides: $-0.40x^2 - 20x - 37.50 = 0$.
Step 8 :Divide both sides by -0.40: $x^2 + 50x + 93.75 = 0$.
Step 9 :Using the quadratic formula, we find that $x \approx -1.87$ or $x \approx -50.13$. Since x represents the number of $0.10$ increases, it must be a positive integer.
Step 10 :Thus, $x = 1$ (rounded to the nearest integer).
Step 11 :Substitute x back into the ticket price equation: $4 + 0.10(1) = 4.10$.
Step 12 :\(\boxed{\$4.10}\)