Step 1 :Given the preference table for an election, we are asked to determine the winner using the Borda count method and to check if the majority criterion is satisfied.
Step 2 :The Borda count method assigns points to each candidate based on their ranking in each voter's preference. In this case, since there are 4 candidates, the 1st choice gets 4 points, the 2nd choice gets 3 points, the 3rd choice gets 2 points, and the 4th choice gets 1 point.
Step 3 :We calculate the total points for each candidate: 'A' gets 256 points, 'B' gets 248 points, 'C' gets 268 points, and 'D' gets 228 points.
Step 4 :The candidate with the highest Borda count is 'C'. Therefore, using the Borda count method, the winner is \(\boxed{C}\).
Step 5 :The majority criterion is satisfied if the candidate who received the majority of first-place votes won the election. In this case, the candidate who received the majority of first-place votes is 'A', but the winner is 'C'.
Step 6 :Therefore, the majority criterion is not satisfied because the candidate who received the majority of first-place votes (\(\boxed{A}\)) did not win the election.